• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • About
  • Shop
  • Press
  • Media Kit
  • Contact

teach mama logo

teach mama

helps families connect & build bridges between home & school, by amy mascott

  • early literacy
    • alphabet
    • beginning sounds
    • phonics
    • phonological awareness
    • read-aloud learning
    • rhyming
    • sight words
  • reading
    • books
    • comprehension
      • activating schema
      • connecting
      • inferring
      • predicting
      • questioning
      • retelling / summarizing
      • visualizing
    • concepts of print
    • environmental print
    • fluency
    • non-fiction
    • spelling
    • word building
    • word consciousness
    • vocabulary
  • writing
    • creative writing
    • grammar
    • informative writing
    • tripod grip
  • math
    • computation
    • counting
    • numbers
  • science
    • animals
    • plants
    • science experiments for kids
  • Activities
    • birthdays
    • cooking
      • new for us foods
    • crafts
    • foundations
      • colors
      • critical thinking
      • fine arts
      • listening
      • pretend play
      • sorting
      • speaking
    • holidays
      • new year’s
      • valentine’s day
      • president’s day
      • st. patrick’s day
      • april fool’s day
      • easter
      • mother’s day
      • teacher appreciation
      • father’s day
      • july 4th
      • halloween
      • thanksgiving
      • christmas
    • family life
      • family fun
      • giving back
      • lunchbox love notes
      • school
    • indoor activities
    • outdoor activities
  • digital literacy
    • computer time
    • iPad for learning
  • early literacy
    • alphabet
    • beginning sounds
    • phonics
    • phonological awareness
    • read-aloud learning
    • rhyming
    • sight words
  • reading
    • books
    • comprehension
      • activating schema
      • connecting
      • inferring
      • predicting
      • questioning
      • retelling / summarizing
      • visualizing
    • concepts of print
    • environmental print
    • fluency
    • non-fiction
    • spelling
    • word building
    • word consciousness
    • vocabulary
  • writing
    • creative writing
    • grammar
    • informative writing
    • tripod grip
  • math
    • computation
    • counting
    • numbers
  • science
    • animals
    • plants
    • science experiments for kids
  • Activities
    • birthdays
    • cooking
      • new for us foods
    • crafts
    • foundations
      • colors
      • critical thinking
      • fine arts
      • listening
      • pretend play
      • sorting
      • speaking
    • holidays
      • new year’s
      • valentine’s day
      • president’s day
      • st. patrick’s day
      • april fool’s day
      • easter
      • mother’s day
      • teacher appreciation
      • father’s day
      • july 4th
      • halloween
      • thanksgiving
      • christmas
    • family life
      • family fun
      • giving back
      • lunchbox love notes
      • school
    • indoor activities
    • outdoor activities
  • digital literacy
    • computer time
    • iPad for learning

develop strong reading skills early: skimming vs reading

home / reading / comprehension / develop strong reading skills early: skimming vs reading
710 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print

strong reading skills skimmingI realized something recently that I should have noticed way before now.

Actually, I had an idea about it, but I wasn’t really for sure for sure.

One of my children has a tendency to move quickly through tasks, working hard to get anything she’s doing finished–but not really paying super close attention to detail.

And this has transferred to her reading: she does a whole lot more skimming while reading than actually reading while reading.

Yes, she can read.

I know that. In fact, she loves to read.

But she’s ‘reading’ so quickly—moving through books so fast now—that I am worried she’s falling into some really poor reading habits, and I’m out to stop it asap.

Here’s the skinny.  . .

  • Develop Strong Reading Skills Early– Skimming vs Reading: Many nights Maddy goes to bed with a pile of books—books that she loves and has read and re-read many times.

I’m fine with that because I want that time before bed—and after we’ve read together—to be purely

pleasurable reading time, all for her.

But lately I’ve questioned the speed with which she’s reading some of her new books on her own; she had been moving really quickly through books that should have taken a bit longer, and she admitted that she wasn’t passing her Accelerated Reader tests at school.

develop strong readers early: skimming vs reading

Eggs, water, and oil were ready.  But something was missing.

This was the real eye-opener for me.

When I asked her how she’s reading so fast, she said, Mommy, I like to ‘skim read’. That way I can get to the good parts faster.

Hmmm. Lovely argument.

Her response made me wonder how much my rush, rush, rush tendencies have rubbed off on her.  Though she’s able to delay gratification with other things—saving money vs spending, claiming that she eats her sandwich at school before her cookies—why was she rushing through texts, and how could I show her that by doing so, she’s missing some really important pieces?

How could I show her that skimming is okay–and suggested!–for some texts but not for others?

develop strong readers early: skimming vs reading

Ahhh, the mix. Yes, the mix.

This weekend, when she asked if she could make quick pumpkin bread on her own—without my help—I thought it could be an absolute perfect time to show her that skimming is not always a good idea.

And it was.

I told her I’d let her go—from start to finish–solo, but she called for help early in.

Where’s the teaspoon thing? I can’t find the teaspoon for the oil part. It says ‘2 teaspoons of oil.’

I looked at the box.  It said tablespoon.  And the tablespoon measure was right there staring up at her from the drawer.

Check again, Maddy.  Make sure you’ve got it right before we go scouring the kitchen for lost utensils.

It says right here (pointing to the box) 2 teasp–.  Oh. Wait. Okay, so tablespoon. Two tablespoons.develop strong readers early: skimming vs reading

Right. Good eye, and I’m glad you double-checked. If you didn’t add enough oil, your cake would be really dry.

She grabbed the tablespoon, poured in the oil, and was on her merry way.

A few minutes later: Mom, something’s not right. I added the eggs and water and the oil but where’s the like cake part?

It says, ‘mix eggs and oil and water’, but is that right?

I looked at the box.  It didn’t say ‘mix eggs and oil and water’; it said, Combine: Mix, oil, eggs, and water.  She was skimming and missed a biggie.

Maddy.  Check again, Sweetheart. Make sure you are correct in reading the directions.

She looked at the box.  It says right here (pointing to the box again) Mix, oil, eggs, and water.  So what’s wrong? I’m supposed to mix this stuff together.

Look again, Maddy, and pay close attention to all of the words and the punctuation. It’s all there for a reason, Honey.  From commas to colons, it’s all included for a reason.

She read again, this time throwing in ‘combine’:  See? Combine mix, oil, eggs, and water. Ooooohhhhhh.  I thought that the ‘mix’ was telling me to mix everything, not that it meant the stuff in the box—the cake mix.

Right. Biiiiig difference, right? So skimming on recipe-reading could mean huge problems for your cake-making. You must move more slowly, take some time, and read every single thing on the box—it’s all important.  By skipping over ‘Combine’ you misunderstood some pretty simple instructions.

You can do this.  Start from ‘Combine’, read closely, and let’s get this cake in the oven.

And so she did.   I only helped hold the heavy bowl as she poured it into the cake batter pan, and later on we all enjoyed some fabulous, warm pumpkin bread thanks to Maddy.

develop strong readers early: skimming vs reading

Once she got rolling, she had. Solo.

It was a learning experience for both Maddy and me. I saw first-hand how she’s skimming, and so did she.

We talked later, at bedtime, about the difference between skimming and reading and what happened earlier in the afternoon with her pumpkin bread.

There’s definitely a time for skimming, I said.  But you need to figure out when it’s a good idea to skim and when you need to read closely, making sure you understand what you’re reading.

I know, she said.  I know.  But no skimming recipes.

Skimming recipes is great when you’re making a grocery list, but not while you’re making the food, right? I asked.But there are some times when skimming is okay.  We can talk about that tomorrow. For now, how about you enjoy your book and turn the light off in five minutes?

I didn’t want to push too much or make her feel uncomfortable, but we develop strong readers early: skimming vs readingwill carry on this conversation for sure–another time.

I like how Tamim Ansary puts it in her article, How to Read (and Not Read) a Book. Though she’s talking about speed of reading, she also talks about skimming:

With reading . . . you can set your own pace. You can skim for an overview, zoom in for details, slow down for deep stuff, soar again to see big connections — there may be an upper limit to your speed, but it’s elastic.

She goes on:

In fact, reading for information may entail reading at many speeds, in many ways: skimming whole chapters, crawling through others while painstakingly reading every word, scanning for particular facts, and jumping from later pages to earlier pages. If you’re doing research, the book is a forest; you’re a hunter stalking game. What the author put in is less important than what you intend to take out.

But read a novel like that and you’ll surely miss what the book has to offer. In fact, nothing said about reading applies universally. . . It’s not just that there are many ways to read. It’s that reading is many different activities.

I love how succinctly she puts it.

Self-monitoring during reading is something I’ll definitely practice with Maddy the next few days and weeks, but until then, I’d say that this recipe-reading-skimming was a pretty solid learning in the every day experience.

Do you have any tips or ideas for handling ‘skimmers’?  I’m always up for learning more–please leave ideas in the comments and let me know!

 

fyi: This blog post is part of an incentivized online influencer network for Mom’s Homeroom. Mom’s Homeroom is brought to you by Frosted Mini-Wheats.

You May Also Like...

  • Navigating Education in a Time of Uncertainty: A Virtual Summit for Educators
    Navigating Education in a Time of Uncertainty: A Virtual Summit for Educators
  • Virtual Summit for Educators: Navigating the Online Classroom & Beyond
    Virtual Summit for Educators: Navigating the Online Classroom & Beyond
  • how to prepare your child for kindergarten -- summertime prep
    how to prepare your child for kindergarten -- summertime prep

About amy mascott

teacher, mother, dreamer. lover of literacy, fun learning, good food, and three crazy-cool kids. finder of four-leaf clovers | dc metro · http://about.me/amymascott
tweet with me: @teachmama

Previous Post: « national book festival 2012: why families need to go
Next Post: keeping families safe while driving: safely go »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Tracee Orman

    October 18, 2012 at 12:25 am

    I’m glad you wrote this, Amy, and I agree with everything except that there’s a time for skimming. I don’t think it’s ever good to skim because you always miss out on something – even on grocery lists. (I can’t tell you how many times my husband missed an item on the list because he skimmed it! lol)

    I think it stems from teaching to the test: as soon as we started giving students timed reading tests we sent them the message that close reading is bad, skimming is good. The Common Core State Standards are emphasizing close reading, and yet timed reading assessments are STILL being used to evaluate students. Something is wrong with this equation. I have never had a job (or a boss) that encouraged me to skim and skip over anything I read. We are doing our students a disservice by teaching skimming because it’s carrying over into everything–like baking bread! 🙂 Until more people speak up about it (and point out the hypocrisy in timed reading tests), I don’t think it’ll change.

    Thank you so much for addressing this issue, Amy!
    -Tracee

    Reply
    • amy

      October 18, 2012 at 9:03 am

      Hey Tracee!! Thanks so much for reading and taking the time to respond! I do think this discussion merits a response because as a reading specialist and former high school English teacher, I feel strongly that as teachers we need to teach students that they have to learn to pull out sorts of different strategies for every situation and that skimming is, in fact, not always the ‘wrong’ thing. When I taught Jurassic Park by Michael Crichton, to my 9th graders, there were serveral passages full of scientific jargon that often stymied even my strongest reader. The kids did not need to read these passages super-close because quite frankly, it wasn’t imperative to understanding the story. For many kids, this novel was the first ‘biggie’ of their lives, and they could very well understand and appreciate the plot, character, and thematic elements without totally wasting hours trying to wrap their heads around the scientific parts. No, I did not tell them to skim the whole book; rather, as a strategy, I invited them to skim to get the basics of these difficult passages and then move on so they could really focus on the rest. I think as students become learners in the digital age, skimming is also important when figuring out if a website is reliable and valid–it’s a strategy that needs to be taught, modeled, and talked about, both as a study skill and reading skill.

      Reply
      • Tracee Orman

        October 18, 2012 at 6:01 pm

        I think that’s a valid point, Amy. I agree that “super close” reading is definitely not necessary for every page of the book. But the idea of skimming literature makes me wonder, what’s the point of reading it? I probably wouldn’t assign it at all if it’s something they would need to skim.

        I think the website skimming is a very good point, too. I was primarily thinking of literature, so thank you for pointing that out! 🙂

        Reply
        • amy

          October 19, 2012 at 8:49 pm

          Tracee–good point as well. I definitely would say that skimming literature is not a common message I promote; however, Jurassic Park is kind of unusual in the scientific jargony passages, and, at the time, it was a no-brainer choice in comparison to the other choices I had to teach. 🙂

  2. PragmaticMom

    October 18, 2012 at 6:04 pm

    I can understand the skim-read to get to the good parts but will she slow down during the 2nd re-read or the one after that? Maybe if she is willing to read 2x everything– once fast, one slow — this is ok?

    Reply
    • amy

      October 19, 2012 at 8:44 pm

      Good question, my friend. I don’t know, to be honest. It’s worth looking into, but as a lifelong skill, reading one text 2x’s is just not practical, right? hmmmmm…

      Reply
  3. Erica Shidle

    October 18, 2012 at 7:45 pm

    I have found with my 7 year old daughter that math word problems have helped her become a more thorough reader. Also the written response questions require her to think about her answer and communicate the process. The quality of her writing for her math problems is so different (concise and clear) compared to her rambling narratives in her writing journal. I think the reading for a purpose that you demonstrated with the recipes was a great example.

    Reply
    • amy

      October 19, 2012 at 8:43 pm

      So interesting, Erica!! Thank you so much for sharing–I agree–math problems really require close reading, and I may just bring a few more of them out as well. Can’t hurt, right!? Huge thanks for reading and thanks a million for taking the time to write!

      Reply
  4. Brandy

    October 21, 2012 at 10:51 pm

    Something hilarious happened today that made me think of this post. We were at the grocery store and out of the blue my five year old says, “What cats do we return, Mama?” I asked him what he was talking about and he pointed to the sign that said “Please Return Carts Here.” Hahaha! I told him to read more closely and he immediately caught it but we had a great laugh over it. It will definitely be one of our inside jokes from here on out.

    Reply
    • amy

      October 22, 2012 at 10:42 am

      BRANDY. I LOVE it. Thank you so so much for sharing–makes me feel like I”m not so alone, my friend. And what a FUN inside joke between you two from here on out. You are seriously one of my faves in the whole wide world. xo

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

our books & freebies

setting the stage for rock-star readers
raise a reader
amy mascott profile blog
subscribe teachmama

join the coolest club around:

Find Us On Social Media

Helpful Links

  • About
  • Contact
  • Press
  • Media Kit
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us On Instagram

View
Open
Hot off the presses!

I've been working CRAZY hours because I'm prepping for a launch in the next two weeks. G U L P!

I'm SUPER excited, and I know you will be too.

Read more here: https://take5.teachmama.com/

#linkinbio #teachmamatake5 #bestoftheweb #take5 #coolestclubintown
View
Open
Loving my new St. Patrick’s Day 🍀 tee and eyeing about 5 others I totally want!

Remember—the more we can get our kids reading, the better! 

So find a fun and festive shirt for everyone in the fam and teach kids phrases like: 

🍀 Saint Patrick’s Day sparks JOY

☘️ Happy Go Lucky

🍀 Team Irish

☘️ Lucky Charm

🍀 Irish I was a little bit taller

☘️ Here for the shenanigans 

🍀 Lucky mama

☘️ A wee bit Irish 

and more!

Right now on Zulily you can grab tees, hoodies, dresses, pj sets, tank tops, slouchy tees, sweatshirts, sweatpants, and more starting at under $20!

Check them out: zulily.gfpv.net/rnegED

#stpatricksdaydecor #linkinbio #saintpaddysday #familyfun🍀 #irishkids #zulilypartner #raiseareader
View
Open
If you have not yet met the Buddha Board, today is your lucky day.

The Buddha Board is the ideal way to help kids find focus and to relax, and honestly every family could use one.

I would do anything some days to bring a little big of peace and calm–and zen–to our home. 

With a Buddha Board always out on a shelf, we are always just minutes away from unplugged focus and relaxation.

Have you tried one? 

Here are the deets:
https://teachmama.com/help-kids-focus-and-relax-with-the-buddha-board/

#linkinbio #buddhaboard #calmyourmind #mindfulmoments #unplugged
View
Open
Doesn’t it seem like time has become a crazy mashup of virtual-hybrid-normal-life, scattered with the *occasional* bright spot—with an overload of disappointment, confusion, and uncertainty? Like it’s hard to pinpoint what happened exactly last spring or the summer before last or even last fall?

It’s all kind of a jumbled mess?

It feels like that for me. 

But I know this for sure: spending time with these women is truly good for my soul. It’s what my heart needs. Time slows down. I can breathe. 

And it’s what I’m betting everyone needs right now—some time with good friends—sister bffs—friends like family. 

No matter what is going on in the world, these women ground me, help me feel more centered, and fill my heart with so. much. joy. 

I walked Louie this morning with what felt like lighter steps and a bigger smile on my face, and I know it’s because I spent time with beloved friends last night. 

Friends, listen to me: It’s EASY to want to hole up right now and not do much of anything—it’s dark by 5pm, it’s freezing out, it’s grey and gross outside, and we are all so tired. But one night this week or next, call a pal. 

Make plans for coffee or a meal together, and just RECONNECT with some friends. Put on a little lipstick. Dust off that bottle of perfume. Wear a big sweater over a tee shirt and leggings and put on fun earrings. It’s not that hard, but it makes a difference. 

I guarantee it will be exactly what you need and you will move forward the next few days with a brighter spirit. 

Love you, @jessicamcfadd @justicefergie and @sandie_chen so, so, SO MUCH. And love Evie too!! 

Let’s get another date on the calendar stat. 😉😍

(Of COURSE we made beautiful @eve.mcfadden pose with us last night after her dance class because we are her bloggy aunties and have known her since she was 2yo and we love her like our own.)

#wwh #bff4life #ogbloggers #sisterfriends
View
Open
Thank you @delegateericluedtke @senzucker @delegatepamqueen for meeting with Maryland @MomsDemand volunteers to discuss how we can work together to end gun violence in our communities. 

JOIN US at our next event by texting READY to 644-33 to get involved in your community!

#MDGA22 #MDpolitics #MomsAreEverywhere #DoSomething #SaySomething #BeTheChange
View
Open
As a @MomsDemand volunteer, I just met virtually with my #MDGA22 legislators to work to keep our state safe from gun violence. 

I told @delegateericluedtke @senzucker @delegatepamqueen that:

- In 1999, I was teaching English at Wilde Lake HS in Columbia, MD when the Columbine HS massacre took place. I vowed then that I would do everything I could to prevent something like that from happening again. I thought: There is NO WAY this will happen when I have children in school. Laws will change. Surely we will protect our children better.

- In 2007, I had just had my 3rd child, and a month later, the VA Tech shooting took place. I watched the news in horror and thought, please, please, PLEASE let smart people make laws to prevent this from ever happening again. PLEASE. 

- In 2012, I had three kids in elementary school--K, 1st, and 3rd grade, and my husband was an admin at a different school. That same year, 20 children and 6 adults were shot and killed at Sandy Hook ES. I joined @sandyhookpromise as soon as it was created. I thought: THIS will be the last one. No more senseless, preventable deaths.

- In 2022, just last week, at Magruder HS, where I once taught English and where my husband coached soccer, there was another shooting. This time with a ghost gun. Every day, I send my 3 children off to high school 10 minutes down the road from Magruder HS, and every day, I plead, pray, and beg God to keep them safe. 

They should not fear for their lives when they walk into school each day, nor should ANY child, any teacher, any administrator, or support staff. Schools should be safe places.

Today, we asked #Maryland lawmakers to prioritize legislation to prohibit the manufacture & sale of ghost guns: do-it-yourself weapons that can be downloaded or purchased online, bypassing the background check system that keeps us all safe. 

Please do the same. Join your local @momsdemand or @studentsdemand 

#UseYourVoice #DoSomething
#MDpolitics #MomsAreEverywhere
View
Open
Although I can’t be in Annapolis today, this Maryland @MomsDemand volunteer stands with those there in urging my legislators to protect our state from ghost guns. #MomsAreEverywhere #MDGA22 #MDpolitics

Want to get involved? 

❤️ visit momsdemandaction.org

❤️ share ANY and ALL @momsdemand @studentsdemand or @everytown posts

❤️ share any and all #MDGA22 #MDpolitics posts 

❤️ join this movement and make a difference!

#DoSomething #SaySomething #BeTheChange #EndGunViolence
View
Open
🔥 Hot off the presses 🔥

Take 5: here's what happened to me, and here's where we're going. . .

Excited about big things happening over here in 2022. 

Things may look a little different as we release and share, but if you want to stay ‘in the know’, subscribe here: https://take5.teachmama.com/

#herewego #thescoop #herearethedeets #linkinbio
View
Open
Time for your New Year’s Family Interview! 

If you haven’t done it yet, it’s OKAY. We are all feeing a little bit behind already this year. 

Be good to yourself. 

Love your people well. 

Head over and grab your *new and improved* New Year’s Family Interviews here: https://shop.teachmama.com/product/new-years-family-interview/

#newyearinterview #familyfun #easytraditions #linkinbio

Copyright © 2022 · teach mama media, llc · All Rights Reserved

  • 2
710 shares